WHIR!! Need help with BIG trade (Foster involved)

[NFL1527]

Hey guys,
I am currently 4-0 in my non-PPR pool. 10-team league, 3 keepers each. I have listed my team down below. Current projected keepers are Foster, Marshall, and Graham....I think.

I have been offered the following trade...

I receive:
QB - My choice of Brady or RGIII
RB - Lynch

I give up:
QB - Vick
RB - Foster

So, the choice here breaks down to is the upgrade at QB from Vick to Brady/RGIII worth the downgrade of Foster (who I selected #1 overall) to Lynch?

Please let me know if any of you would do this deal or not, and if you would do this deal let me know which QB you'd prefer. Thanks! WHIR 100%


Current team:
QB - Vick
RB - Foster
RB - Gore
WR - Marshall
WR - Nicks
WR - T.Smith
TE - Graham
----
QB BN - Romo
RB BN - Martin, Green-Ellis
WR BN - Hartline, Roberts, Floyd, Cobb

[chopperjames619]

Its hard for me to give up Foster, He's killing it every weekend, Besides your 4-0, you're not the one hurting right now. My opinion no trade.Romo and vick are wildcards but I would wait until you are in trouble. help with mine its the marshall greenellis trade.

[MadDog36]

I'd be happy wtih Vick and Romo as my team since you have a solid rest of team.

[coolmar100]

I am personally a big believer in great production from the QB spot. To me the upgrade from Vick a borderline top 10 QB to a top 5 QB is definitely worth the downgrade from a top 3 RB to a top 10 RB. This is also partially because I love Brady or RGIII so much more than Vick and Romo. I would do the deal, but since you are 4-0 it may be a bit wiser to not try and fix what isn't broken.

[MurdaSquad]

I would say that's a decent trade. the numbers you're gonna get out of
rg3/lynch are gonna surpass those of fosters. I had foster as well, traded him
away for Julio, gore and turner

[xclusive1987]

Definitely do it. I would probably go Brady, but I may be in the minority there.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=524638

[brianj29]

hmm its tough id say yes if u get rg111 in keeper

[NoCandle]

I would do that trade especially if you get RG3 because he gets both rush and pass yards and is a more accurate passer than Vick. I honestly think Lynch and Foster are two of the best. This season Lynch gets more carries because he has an inconsistent rookie QB so yeah do it.


Heres my link: viewtopic.php?t=524702

[sjabbs55]

I like RG3 and Lynch. Lynch is beastmode we know this, and the only real threat in Seattle. RG3 is putting up monster rookie season #'s. He is the younger and improved version of vick. I don't like Romo or Vick this season. Romo doesnt get enough time to even drop back with that crappy o-line of his. Vick is getting a lot of pressure due to his crappy o-line as well and hasn't been as elusive as before.

Ride out RG3s rookie hot streak and let lynch eat skittles while racking up the yards.

BTW thanks for your response on my thread

[eleusive]

i'd do that trade! i would go for brady and lynch. Romo and Vick aren't consistent, but Brady is and when he goes off...HE GOES OFF.
You would get a little degrade (just a little bit) in RB, but a huge upgrade in QB