BIG TRADE ADVICE WHIR

[NoCandle]

I am in a standard scoring league. Its an Individual Player defense though and I need you guys to decide if this trade is fair or not! Post links to yours and I will respond to them ASAP

I give: Jamaal Charles and DaMarcus Ware

I get: Reggie Bush, Antonio Gates and Aldon Smith

Heres my roster:

QB: Tom Brady (No backup but there a few in the free agency so im not worried about that)

RB: Jammal Charles, Ryan Williams, Shonn Greene and Brandon Boldin (not in order)

WR: Miles Austin, Anquan Boldin, Sidney Rice, Jeremy Kerley and Mario Manningham (Not in
order)
TE: Jason Witten and Joel Dreessen

K: Stephen Gostowski

Defensive Backs(3 start): Ed Reed, Malcolm Jenkins, Dashon Goldson, Patrick Peterson, Brandon Flowers and Tramon Williams

Defensive Line(3 start): Haloti Ngata, Charles Johnson, Justin Tuck and Cameron Jordan

Linebackers (3 start): Von Miller, Damarcus Ware, Donald Butler, Stephen Tulloch and Luke Kuechly

What to you guys think?

[Twlong223]

I have no experience with the IDP setup but this trade doesn't seem that great for you. You don't need Gates as you have witten and Charles > Bush. Those are my thoughts at least. Not sure how the defensive players skew things

[BoyNamedSue]

Thanks for the help with my trade post.

I'm also in an IDP league so I feel your pain.

I have to agree that Witten>Gates and Charles>Bush.
Gates just isn't going to have the type of 12 catch games Witten has/will have.

Charles and Bush have less of a gap b/t their skills but I would stick with Charles as he'll be fed on a more consistent basis especially as KC figures out the QB situation.

Ware has more upside than Smith but they're close.
They both get to the QB, Ware a bit more. Ware also gets more tackles and FF.

I'd stay as you are.