Which RB to get for Harvin & SJax?

[ob187]

You think these are pretty even trades?

a) Give Harvin & SJax for Ray Rice
b) Give Luck, Harvin & SJax for McCoy and Garcon
c) Give SJax & Harvin for MJD & Wallace

I'm 3-2 and have the most points in the league
12 team, h2h, standard, non-ppr, 6pt/td
1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1flex, 1te, 1td, 1pk

QB: Matt Ryan, Andrew Luck
RB: DMC, Steven Jackson, Chris Johnson, Daniel Thomas, Daryl Richardson, Joquim Bell, Robert Turbin
WR: Vicor Cruz, Percy Harvin, Roddy White, Brandon LaFell, Titus Young, Jerome Simpson
TE: Jimmy Graham
PK: Matt Bryant
TD: Green Bay Packers

[MetsAllTheWay]

I would go with deal C first. I don't like A for you because I think it leaves you a big hole at your WR3

[ob187]

How about B?

Give Luck, Harvin & SJax for McCoy and Garcon

[TheBeaker]

Personally I like C as well. just seems to fit for the lineup as a whole.

[Mean One]

How about B?

Give Luck, Harvin & SJax for McCoy and Garcon

I wouldn't give up Luck until Ryan finishes his BYE week. I would deal first from your strength (WR) before going to another position (QB). Don't know what the other team's QB situation is like but don't place your roster in a bind with no adequate backup as a replacement.

If anything, try Harvin/SJax for McCoy and see if he is interested. You would have a better chance of acquiring McCoy than you would Rice at this time.

[weig0132]

I would go with C, it doesn't leave a gaping hole in your WR's.

please help, viewtopic.php?f=18&t=524904

[millenniumfalcon]

I would go with C also

viewtopic.php?t=524907

[TheLeague1907]

I like C as well worse RB and better WR for better RB and worse WR
fair for both sides

[hotpocket]

C, however if I was the guy giving up MJD and Wallace I wouldn't do it.