Rivers for Luck? WHIR

[winningallthesports]

The Phil Rivers-Antonio Gates tandem has been seriously underwhelming this season, and I'm wondering if its time to make a change. On the other hand, the Luck-Wayne duo has been amazing, and I already have one half of that with Reggie Wayne. Is Luck worth giving up Rivers, who despite the slow start is still considered one of the leagues elite? Also, should I stick it out with Gates or start to look for other options? I have Pitta on my bench but Torrey Smith is also one of my starting receivers so they would eat into each others production if I have to start both.

[LJ's Crush]

I would trade for luck I expect Indy to be throwing alot go for him.

viewtopic.php?t=524932

[faitdavid]

Absolutely do this. Rankings? I would have Luck at about 10 and Rivers 14. Maybe even higher for Luck and lower for Rivers. The rookie is only getting better. And hold on to Gates for now.

[winningallthesports]

another factor is that Luck plays Houston in the first week of the playoffs whereas Rivers plays Carolina. of course I have to get to the playoffs first so for now its irrelevant but could be a factor later

[brianj29]

i still like rivers but luck has been great
help
viewtopic.php?t=524968

[hotpocket]

I would roll the dice with Luck.