Best Trade for TE

[Big Blue WC]

I am tired of Jermichael Finley. Here are two trade scenarios. Which do you like better?
1. Give up Ben Tate and Jermichael Finley to get Antonio Gates and Felix Jones (I have DeMarco Murray and the guy I'd be trading with has Arian Foster).

2. Trade Alex Green straight up for Martellus Bennett (Guy I'm trading with has Cedric Benson)

[machine3]

I like #2 better.