Which of these 2 trades would you do? WHIR!!!

[Eastman19]

Would you rather give Ridley and Nelson for: McFadden and Andre Johnson or Ray Rice and Dez Bryant...PPR league and non keeper.

[bigdogg712]

Would you rather give Ridley and Nelson for: McFadden and Andre Johnson or Ray Rice and Dez Bryant...PPR league and non keeper.

Probably mcfadden and andre. More consistent than Rice and Dez. If you do the first one, you'll be more well rounded

Help me out?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=525325

[Mean One]

I would go with Rice and Dez, but by a slim margin.

Rice makes this trade while Dez is nothing more than a throw-in because of his inconsistencies on the field. It would shape up that you would start both Austin and Dez in your WR slots (both Cowboys, not the best of combos) but to pair Rice with Foster would free you up to persue better WR options in trades with the abundance of starting RB's you have on your bench.

[Eastman19]

bump

[Eastman19]

I have to update my roster...I don't have Austin anymore...I have Julio Jones!!

[hotpocket]

Good pickup on Jones. I think if you ever have a decent deal on getting Rice, you take it.

Once that's said and done, you are looking pretty good at RB, I would try and trade one or make a package for another really good WR. If it were me, I'd want something more consistent than Nelson/Dez.

[Reddot]

Close one but I like Mcfadden and AJ. While R. Rice is the more consistent of the 2 backs, I love Mcfadden in PPR and Andre is enough to seal the deal as Dez is nearly useless right now

[c0megets0me]

I think someone would have to be stupid to give up any of those for Ridley/Nelson. I would lean slightly toward DMC/AJ

[Seibs]

Personally I'd take Rice and Bryant. But that's coming from my point of view of a standard league. Both WR's have problems with consistency, especially Bryant. But I think that the difference between Rice and McFadden is large enough that it's worth taking that extra inconsistency (well, right now it's not even inconsistency) with the potential for better play in the future because let's face it, Bryant's play can't fall from here...

[csirus]

Personally I'd take Rice and Bryant. But that's coming from my point of view of a standard league. Both WR's have problems with consistency, especially Bryant. But I think that the difference between Rice and McFadden is large enough that it's worth taking that extra inconsistency (well, right now it's not even inconsistency) with the potential for better play in the future because let's face it, Bryant's play can't fall from here...

I'd have to agree with him on this one, I believe Rice would be a solid back to snatch up. His good games are good enough to make him worth the risk.