j.jones, mccoy for charles and mjd. WHIR

[thebrokenbox]

I've been offered this trade. It will be my Jones and Mccoy for his Charles and MJD.

QB-Matt Ryan
WR- Julio Jones
WR-A.J. Green
WR- Eric Decker
RB- Lesean McCoy
RB- Demarco Murray
TE- Kyle Rudolph
Q/W/R/T- Andy Dalton
BN-Danny Amendola
BN- Pierre Garcon
BN- Alex Green
BN-Andrew Hawkins
BN-Vick Ballard

I guess you could say Im kind of deep at WR, and I honestly think this trade favors me, but just want your guys opinions. This league is a 1 point ppr. Thanks!

[LMack]

The value is probably fair but with your team and these roster settings I would not do the deal. You think you are deep at WR? I'd say your RB and WR depth are pretty close.

This would force Garcon or Hawkins into your lineup on a weekly basis. It would also force Murray onto your bench because you are better off starting Dalton at your flex than any RB. I think the upgrade at your RB is small to moderate, your downgrade at WR is significant, and it pushes a lot of wasted value in the form of Demarco Murray onto your bench.

i just don't see how this makes your team that much better in a PPR league.

[thebrokenbox]

Alright, thanks so much for your input! I guess I didn't look at it like that. If Amendola hadn't been hurt I feel like this would be great.

[LMack]

Alright, thanks so much for your input! I guess I didn't look at it like that. If Amendola hadn't been hurt I feel like this would be great.

I would feel a lot better about a healthy Amendola as your WR3 in a PPR league than Hawkins or Garcon, definitely.

And I agree with your assessment of the overall value of the trade. It just doesn't mesh well with your current roster.