my newton/gronk/lynch for luck/johnson/smith/cook?

[spyder0314]

team in sig. I traded my cam newton/gronkowski/lynch for his luck/andre johnson/torrey smith/cook. I needed wr and other owner needed rb and cam is on bye this week so i benefited from playing luck this week as well. I think my only regret is losing gronk for cook, but i have gresham on bench. What do you guys think? good or bad for me?

[spyder0314]

anyone? WHIR!

[big.d57]

I think you lost the deal. Newton should bounce back eventually but trading him for Luck isn't a bad return. Gronk is a much better TE than Cook for sure. Lynch is a beast and I don't really like Johnson too much since he's in a run happy offense. You gave up the two best players in this deal in Gronk and Lynch in my opinion.

[bois13]

I agree that I think you lost the trade. Luck is very good but wont do that much better than newton if at all. You gave up a top TE and top RB for a much lesser TE in cook (with not that good of QBs) and a top 5 RB for a very injury prone Andre Johnson. You probably could have gotten a ton more for that combination of players

help me out if you can viewtopic.php?f=18&t=525422