Carson P and Steven Jackson for Vick and CJ2K? WHIR

[NormDynasty]

Who gets the better of this deal?
Would you do either straight up position for position separately?

Thx (WHIR)

[PrinceEatMeat]

I'd take Vick and CJ easily. Palmer just isn't very good. Vick is a huge upgrade there in my opinion. And it's looking like CJ is bouncing back, while Jackson looks pretty much finished and is always hurt.

Please help with mine!
viewtopic.php?t=525638

[wtr23]

Agreed. SJax is a downgrade from Johnson, even though he has disappointed for most of the year he should turn things around, don't see it happening for Jackson though. And even though Vick is struggling now he is still playing better than palmer.

[woods_opc]

Again agreed. The upside of both CJ and Vick is too big to pass up.

http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=525680

[sans_abri]

thx for your help.

yeah, i'd go with the CJ and Vick side. I think i like cj over sj right now, as scary as that sounds. SJ is tough as nails, but he's always hurt and hasn't even broken 85 total yards in 5 games yet. Hard to trust at this point.

[Reddot]

Vick and CJ are probably the stronger combo, but I do think Palmer is going to put up top 10 Qb production from week 7 forward- just a hunch! Also SJ might be more consistent as the season goes on. I'd gamble here and take the latter 2