dynasty trade: titus young for mendenhall? WHIR

[mzkp54]

I desperately need a 2nd RB. I have been offered Mendenhall for Young. Here is my roster:

12 team non-IDP Dynasty PPR Start 1QB, 2 RB, 2WR, 1 TE, 2 RB/WR/TE
QB- Newton, Hasselbeck, Cassel,
RB- Lynch, Redman, Starks, Tate, Williams, Jacobs, Andre Brown
WR- Wallace, Smith (CAR),MFloyd (SD), Lafell, VBrown, Young, RMoss, Morgan
TE- Graham, Finley, Chandler, Moeaki
DST- Texans

I was thinking of countering with either Lafell or Finley, but Young for Mendy could work as well. Thoughts?

[Mean One]

Finley or LaFell won't do it for you because of their lack of production to date. You need a RB for sure. I would do the trade as is because you can replace Young easier than you can acquire a RB.

[mzkp54]

bump

[Hawkeye1]

I'd roll the dice on Mendenhall. Young just isn't producing.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=526072

[TheLeague1907]

Calvin is always gonna be in Young's way id say him for Mendy is fine
Thanks for helping me

[wewantceezy]

Young is weak. Take Mendy all day.

[mzkp54]

made the deal