Giving up too much for Roddy White?? WHIR!

[notorious623]

12 team H2H standard scoring (no PPR) - start 2 RBs, 2 WRs, and a Flex

Here are my RBs/WRs:

RB: Ray Rice, Reggie Bush (Fred Jackson, Kendall Hunter, Bilal Powell)
WR: Hakeem Nicks, Vincent Jackson (James Jones, Heyward-Bey, Andre Roberts)
Flex: James Jones

Here is what I've been offered:

Reggie Bush and James Jones for Roddy White and CJ Spiller

While gaining Roddy is huge, I would have to start CJ Spiller or Fred Jackson as my RB2... would I be giving up too much? Or should I go through with the trade?

Leave your link and I'll help you out

[gregtucker87]

I like this trade. Roddy is a beast and a huge upgrade in the WR position and with Buffalo having a much easier 2nd half of the season I think both cj and fred will produce. thanks for mine

[Toolbox88]

I don't think you're giving up too much. White is a great addition and Spiller should be ok. I'd say go for it.

[rcarson]

You're getting the two best players in the deal, go accept it before the other guy changes his mind! Roddy is an absolute stud, and brings instant stability to your WR's. You already have Ray Rice, and with all other positions looking good, you can afford to be "weak" at RB2, even though I wouldn't consider Spiller a weak RB2. That looks like a very good roster for a 12 team league, I'd accept that trade in a heartbeat.

[Doctor P]

yeah man, I'd take that deal!

[jhack836]

y are u even thinkng about it!!!??? i hope you go accept right now, i would trade both of them for just roddy

[goodwidp]

Definitely a good deal for you and you still have strong options at RB2 (i.e Spiller) so this is definitely an overall upgrade for you. Do it.


Thanks for your help with mine.

[cbs525]

Yes i would definitely take that deal. CJ Spiller and Roddy White are doing great.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=526360

[SirGrotius]

I had to read that a couple times. Definitely do it. Don't worry about the timeshare. Spiller will take the bulk of the carries by end of season.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=526413