Was this trade fair?

[circsmonky]

ok, not my trade but a couple people in my league started screaming after this trade that its unfair. they didnt look at the teams just the trade. opinions?

Team 2 gets
Vick Ballard (Ind - RB)
Martellus Bennett (NYG - TE)
William Powell (Ari - RB)

Team 1 gets
DeMarco Murray (Dal - RB)
Andy Dalton (Cin - QB)


Team 1
Aaron Rodgers
Torrey Smith
Kenny Britt
Brandon Marshall
Trent Richardson
Maurice Jones-Drew
Kyle Rudolph
Fred Davis
Joique Bell
Devin Hester
Vick Ballard
Martellus Bennett
William Powell
Cedric Benson
Justin Tucker
Chicago
St. Louis


Team 2
Robert Griffin III
Mike Wallace
Randall Cobb
Earl Bennett
DeMarco Murray
Andy Dalton
Owen Daniels
Marcedes Lewis
LeSean McCoy
DeSean Jackson
Demaryius Thomas
Carson Palmer
Lawrence Tynes
Pittsburgh
Arizona

[Chaoyi Shih]

basically 3 ww player for injuried elite RB and decent QB2
only fair if it's large league with huge roster and starter

[endlessMike]

That trade helps team 2 for 1 week maybe 2 and then they're screwed the rest of the season. Bad trade.

[circsmonky]

We are 12 teams QB, WRx3, RBx2, TE, W/R/T, K, Def, BNx6, IR there are a few teams that have hoarded some RB and WR so anyone looking for someone its slim pickens.

[duffoholic]

While the trade is unfair, unless you suspect collusion, I don't think it is crazy. Maybe team 2 knows more about Murray's injury than we do. He is getting two 'starting' RB's in return...

[circsmonky]

no collusion here for sure. just wanted some opinions from others. Team 2 needed RBs and thats how he got them.