Should I Trade Nicks for Spiller?

[douvy]

Here is my roster:

RB: Jamaal Charles, DeMarco Murray (injured), Steven Jackson, Mikel Leshoure, Alex Green
WR: Marques Colston, Hakeem Nicks, Dez Bryant, Kenny Britt, Greg Jennings

I am debating accepting this trade because I feel that I am stronger at the WR position than the QB position. Right now with DeMarco hurt I don't even feel like I have a solid RB2. I think Spiller, although in a timeshare with Freddy, is reliable and consistent and better than any of my backs besides Charles.

What do you guys think? Thanks!

[Cinemafreak1]

I would not do it. Give Nicks 1-2 more weeks to see if his worth increases above Spiller. I actually traded Spiller for Julio when Spiller was a beast. Now, with Jackson back it could go either way. Yes, I know Spiller had a good game, but lets face it Cruz will get double teamed and Nicks will benefit.

viewtopic.php?t=526817

[Phildozer]

Spiller is a beast, even with 8 carries he got 90 all purpose and a td. The bills will give him more touches and either way he is the most explosive rb in the league and Nicks has too much competition and injury issues to be relied upon. Trade away top 20 Wr for top 15 Rb any time.