Trade help! Blockbuster

[Khutch]

hey guys I was recently offered jamaal charles, gates and sproles for for my forte graham and powell. Thoughts? also I countered with isaac redman instead of powell for me and and mcfadden instead of charles for him.


Standard Yahoo 14 team league
My starting roster is:

Qb: dalton, Wilson
2 Rb: forte, mjd, powell, redman
3 wrs: AJ, desean, brown and burleson.
Te: graham
Kicker: graham HOUS
D: arizona

Thanks for any input

[Cinemafreak1]

I like the counter offer!

viewtopic.php?t=526817

[littlevickle]

I think its a great trade, Gates should be solid going forward and who knows the extent of Grahams injury and how that affects his play time. I definitely would rather have McFadden than Charles. Go for it

[Khutch]

I don't know if he'll accept the counter offer, would you still do the original trade that he offered me?

[meh8653]

I like the first trade Charles and sproles are studs and gates finally looked good

[littlevickle]

See what he says first, if you have to then go with Charles. But Powell is and will be more valuable than Redman and if you can basically trade Redman for Sproles then you end up winning because everything else is basically a lateral move.