Gates or Miller for S Johnson? WHIR 100%

[con-vicks]

So i asked around if i should trade Miller but now im second guessing if Miller is the one i should shop around or if Gates is the one. Im pretty sure that i can get S Johnson, not only its his bye but the owner just lost Fred Davis...blood in the water!!!! Which one should i offer?


Thanks! Leave a link and ill help!

[DTMan]

I think Gates is the better scorer but Miller is the better value. I'd rather trade Gates b/c I think you'll get more for him, but if what you're getting is Johnson either way, you probably have to send him Miller.

Could you offer Gates and someone else for Johnson and someone else, where you get the better "someone else"?

Quick thoughts on mine? viewtopic.php?t=527300

[macmillanben1]

I'm hoping Gates builds on last game, I'd much rather send Miller to get Johnson, and Miller probably has the most trade value anyways.

[kcspaz14]

I think Miller has the better season. Gates has been trash until last week. Now is the time to sell him while he's hot and has the big name.

Big Ben said he's getting Miller to the Pro Bowl. I believe him.

[duffoholic]

I'd trade Gates in a heartbeat. If you can get the deal to go, do it!

help please,
viewtopic.php?t=527288

[con-vicks]

Everybody hating on Gates!?! Im so worried that he will be solid from here on out...I know Miller will be solid and consistent all year but like last week Gates can have those BIG games...i just need him to be consistent the other weeks