matty ice, maclin, and shon greene, for arron rodgers WHIR!

[the prize fighter]

So I don't really think i need to do this but i offered somebody Matt Ryan, Shon Greene, and MAclin for aaron rodgers.

My team right now.
Qb's- matt ryan, Vick
RB's- AP, Lasean, murray, shonn Greene
Wr's Brandon Masrshall, Demaryius Thomas, and randal cobb, Malcin

We start
1 Qb
2 Rb
2 WR
1 Rb/wr flex

Should i do this trade.. I think i have a real good depth on the bench, What it comes down to is If i feel Rodgers will be that much better than Ryan? What are your thoughts? Leave a link WHIR!! p.s. pretty much i think i'm selling matt ryan high right?

[duffoholic]

Selling high on Greene is a good idea I think. I might try this trade with Vick first and see if he bites. The upgrade really doesn't seem that substantial to give up the depth you're losing. If you really want Rodgers for the rest of the season though and don't think Matt can sustain his pace, you aren't losing any starters... sooo... go for it?

viewtopic.php?t=527288

[DTMan]

Yeah, I'd do it. Rodgers is special, Maclin and Greene are not. Seems like a trade where both sides will win because I assume the other guy can use Maclin and Greene more than you can and he still ends up with a really good QB.

Thanks for the help on mine. I'd been trying to talk myself into Bowe and your post reminded me that I don't really want him.

Dan

[the prize fighter]

a little more opinions please! WHIR!

[kman711]

Do it Rogers the rest of th the rest of the season makes your tea craz crazy elite green not even your s and you would star Cobb ove Macklin every time

Help with mine viewtopic.php?t=527338

[SaveSaturday]

Do it!

Nobody, even Matt Ryan, can compete with Aaron Rodgers and you are selling high on him but mostly on Shonn Green. You can easily live without Maclin as well.

[chibears814]

I like this trade a lot for you. You have good depth and A. Rodgers is a HUGE upgrade. Won't hurt you in any way unless one of your recievers go down with injury

viewtopic.php?t=527330

[Cinemafreak1]

[quote="duffoholic"]Selling high on Greene is a good idea I think. I might try this trade with Vick first and see if he bites. The upgrade really doesn't seem that substantial to give up the depth you're losing. If you really want Rodgers for the rest of the season though and don't think Matt can sustain his pace, you aren't losing any starters... sooo... go for it?

I agree, thanks for the post.

[pelletierry]

I would def try that, you do have enough depth and rodgers would make you unstoppable.

[Seibs]

I'd do it. Considering all the depth that you have for the other positions you're giving away it looks like you're getting pretty much a straight upgrade for Ryan. You're not giving away any of your other starters which is nice, but you're losing a little bit of depth which might hurt you if some of your players go down. But that's a small price to pay in getting Rodgers IMO.