McFadden for Mathews?!?!?!? 100% WHIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[LWCrunner55]

I got offered the following trade...

I give up: Darren McFadden

I receive: Ryan Mathews

Both have great matchups on down the line (playoffs included). Neither has played up to their potential. Should I make this deal??? Or should I sit on McFadden and hope for the best???

[i_b_sparks]

I'd keep Mcfadden personally. They've both under performed and they're both injury risks, but I feel like Mcfadden has the biggest upside of the 2. He's been the victim of a new offensive system and a new head coach but I gotta think they find a way to get their issues figured out soon and get on the same page. He's too big of a weapon for Oakland to not utilize. Good luck!

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=527411

[Mean One]

Tough choice but I would stick with DMC.

[burnsy706]

I like mathews, more potent overall offense. SD seems to be over battle. Loses some 3rd down work, but look at DMC's o line... I have both so obviously im hoping things turn around.