I like the trade. I'm an Eagles fan, so I've seen all of the Eagles games, and Vick is playing extremely poorly--making bad decisions (INTs), not protecting the ball AT ALL when he runs (fumbles), and his offensive line is terrible, so he's getting crushed on every drop back. I expect him to either get hurt or benched before too long.
The risk is that McCoy of Charles get hurt. However, you have Hillis, so I think you'd be covered if Charles got hurt. You simply roll the dice with McCoy. SJax has ahistory of getting hurt anyhow, so he may not be any better hedge. Perhaps you could get the other owner to throw in an average RB (slightly better than your backups, but nothing too good (like a Donald Brown or Alex Green for example).
Please help me. viewtopic.php?t=527688