Hi guys, I just came across this website and it's great! I was reading the "Commissioners should never veto trades!" post and generally I couldn't agree more. (also, trades just go through automatically... there is no approval process in this league. IMO people can manage their teams how they see fit and that has been the rule since day 1) However, a situation has arisen in my league. I am the Commish and I was involved in a trade that sent about half the league into an uproar. Here's the deal...
His team is 2-5. My team is 4-3.
I traded him my Eli Manning, Miles Austin, DeSean Jackson, and Tony Gonzalez
for his Drew Brees, Victor Cruz and Cecil Shorts.
About half the league says the deal is fair. The other half is freaking out because they think the 2-5 team got housed in the deal. The other relevant info is that the 2-5 team is a new player. I am looking for some unbiased opinions here, so any responses would be awesome. If you want the league settings and the team rosters before the trades took place, just let me know and I will post them.