Mike Vick or Andrew Luck

[eseat]

Who should I start at QB
Mike Vick vs Falcons
or
Andrew Luck vs Titans

Thanks

[Ronak]

I really feel Luck is gonna have a good game. Tennessee is terrible and Vick is dealing with bad weather. That means more turnovers for me.

please look at mine

viewtopic.php?t=527892

[mpt3489]

I have this same situation right now. It is really close. Luck has the better matchup, but Vick is at home coming off a bye. Earlier in the week I decided to go with Vick. But this morning with reports of rain and over 20 mph wind in Philly, I'm thinking the Eagles might go run heavy. This could mean some dump passes to McCoy though, which would still get Vick points and Vick may run more than usual. I just don't like the impact the looming storm could cause. Despite Luck being on the road (where he hasn't played well). Vick isn't a great passer and in heavy wind and rain, he suddenly gets a bit worse. I am going with Andrew Luck.

[petemang]

I am in the same situation...and heres my thoughts.

I have been starting Luck for the last 4 weeks because I got fed up with Vick. However, I'm going back to Vick this week and heres why. Eagles coming off a bye so Vick should be the healthiest he will be all year minus week 1. Also, Andy Reid doesn't lose after a bye (this really means little to Vicks fantasy status but you gotta think they will come out with a little fire)

That's my positive for Vick, now my negative for Luck is that he is away. Look at his scoring. He does well at home and poor on the road.

I'm sure since I'm using logic it will come back to bite me because it has all season. Good Luck

[noe@felpme]

Since Vick might have to play through bad weather, I would go with Luck.

[petemang]

everyone above is making a really good point about the weather...I didn't even think about that when I posted. I think that changes my opinion completely and go with Luck....Good "Luck" (not over used at all (sarcasm))

[circsmonky]

Im fight with the Decision of Matt Ryan or Luck. Ryan dealing with all the same stuff Vick is I'm leaning towards Luck but ESPN said they think Matt Ryan is still gonna do good. then they said the wind is over 30 mph and constantly changing direction... im going with Luck, you should too.

[petrieslastword]

80% chance of rain and heavy wind in Philly, so I'm going Luck. I've agonized over this same decision all week.

[giantss88]

Ive been dealing with the same question and I have Luck in. Tennesee allows the most TD's in the air, top 5 in YPG allowed to QB. I wanted to go Vick coming off the bye playing his old team playing for his job. But the weather and those stats above have me thinking Luck

viewtopic.php?t=527927

[circsmonky]

i know its only half time but Luck is keeping the ball on the ground again, grrr. Ryan has 3 passing TD, and Vicks not doing much. I went with Luck, Ryan outscoring him by 20 right now.... I hope Luck over Vick works you you guys clearly i should have stuck with Matty Ice