Turner/Harvin for Richardson/Titus Young

[mgaska84]

I got a trade proposal...

I give M. Turner and Percy Harvin for Trent Richardson and Titus Young. Yes/no? Help me pppplease.

Newton
Turner/Morris/Brown/Williams
Harvin/Marshall/Brown/Moore/Gibson/Britt
Graham/Daniels
Broncos
Walsh

[BleedBlue25]

I would definitely do Turner for Richardson as Turner is starting to hit the brakes on his career. However, I don't think that Harvin would be worth only Titus Young. Sure Titus has taken over Burlesons (SP?) role but I think Harvin is more of a weapon. The upside to this trade would be that Harvin is facing a really tough rest of the season so there is a chance he could be slowed down some. I personally would hold off to see how Titus does this week and then make your decision. Hopefully my rant was somewhat helpful!

[Sums]

PPR league?
If so I would make the trade because Turner is useless in PPR and i love grabbing richardson to upgrade your RB's. Titus young will be a solid 6-7 catches and 70-80yrds a game with a TD here and there being the 2nd WR in a pass happy offense. Sure he is a downgrade to Harvin but I like trade none the less.

[pedigo328]

Definitely not. Love the Richardson addition, hate the Harvin subtraction. Harvin is showing that he will easily be a top 5 finisher this year, and he does it all: Catches, Rushes, Returns...who could ask for more. I'd ask for much more then Young.