Need Help ..Huge KEEPER Trade! WHIR

[friedrich15]

12 team PPR $100 auction keeper league..we can keep any 3 players

been offered Ryan Matthews $13 and Demaryius Thomas $11 and Steve Smith $6 for my AP $19 and Jimmy Graham $8

what do you guys think i really like thomas but have a hard time parting with AP

Vick
A Smith

AP
R Bush
Blount
P Thomas
Gerhart

Nicks
J Jones
DhB
Lafell
Blackmon

Witten
Graham

[friedrich15]

top

[Mean One]

I would imagine both AP and Graham are 2 of your 3 keepers so giving them up in a trade is tough unless you get equal, if not better, value in return. I don't have much faith in Mathews staying injury-free the remainder of the season and Thomas is just as good as Nicks. The $3 salary difference in your favor does little to swing this trade towards acceptance. I would stay put with AP and Graham unless you get more in return.

[mycuccismells]

I agree i wouldnt do this deal. Graham is a great value at $8 so trading him away should be low on your priorities. I dont like giving up AP but if you could package him with a mid level receiver (Dez Bryant value) for those 2 guys i think it would be a better deal

viewtopic.php?t=528421

[friedrich15]

top

[friedrich15]

anyone else on this deal?