QB Dilemma - Vick or Freeman WHIR

[lefthandedforlife]

I have to decide by game time tomorrow to play Michael Vick or Josh Freeman. Freeman has been on fire and is facing Oakland but Vick is playing the Saints.

What are your thoughts?

Post a link and I'll try to help you too.

[jonkb88]

I'll take Vick in the Dome against the worst pass defense in the league. I also think he didn't like the idea of his job coming into question. I feel he'll play inspired football on Monday night. I like Freeman, but the trip to the left coast will have a small effect I think. Vick by a small margin for me.

Good Luck

[noe@felpme]

I second jonks thoughts. The eagles are a cornered animal and the saints have a garbage defense.

[Twlong223]

The good news is you can't really go wrong with a choice like this. That being said, I actually don't like Vick this week, or any week really. On paper this looks like a great matchup, but the saints have shown some defensive aptitude when they play at home. Not always, but I have a gut feeling that the saints want this win more than Vick. Stick with freeman, he is on fire and has the hapless raiders this week.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=528587