Dynasty megadeal? WHIR

[mzkp54]

So my team is in some trouble, specifically at RB. PPR. We start 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE and a flex.

Here it is:

QB- Newton, Cassel, Hasselbeck
RB- Lynch, Mendenhall, Redman, ABrown, Starks, DWill, Tate, Jacobs
WR- Wallace, SSmith (CAR), Floyd, Bess, Lafell, Tate, JMorgan, RMoss
TE- Graham, Finley, Chandler, Moeaki
D- Houston

I was offered the following trade:

I give: Graham, Wallace, Mendenhall
I get: JCharles, Andre Johnson, and Antonio Gates.

I'm considering it. Thoughts?

EDIT: Turned down the original deal- now possibly swapping out Wallace for Malcolm Floyd.

[ScissorMeTimbers]

Honestly I wouldn't take it, it is a tough choice though. I think you should wait until Rashard comes back (hopefully next week) before you worry too much about your RB.I don't like Jamaal Charles over Mendenhall, he plays for a garbage offense, I also wouldn't want to lose Mike Wallace for Johnson in a 3 WR set up.

You downgrade at WR and TE to upgrade for a RB that plays on a team that couldn't score a single TD this week. I wouldn't do it.

[Thundercat]

Don't do it! Period. IMO you'd be giving up too much for a whole lotta nothing. Good Luck!

[DirtDiver]

Thanks with mine. I agree with the two above. I would not do this. Charles plays for a horrible offense who are always behind and are always throwing...most of the time they are interceptions..so he doesn't have the chance to run. Plus..I haven't heard about his injury yet..and how severe it is.

[bill11011]

I agree with those that say don't do it as written. You give up too much, even if you like Johnson over Wallace.

[Chowdaheads]

Thanks for help w mine... I also would not do it. But close. Mendy is so fragile... makes it tempting. But Graham is just ultra valuable in dynasty given his age. And Wallace rivals Andre in value imo.

[mzkp54]

Thanks guys- I turned it down. Giving up too much youth and potential

[mzkp54]

Do you like it any more if I swap out Malcolm Floyd for Mike Wallace?

[winningallthesports]

its much more appealing without having to give up wallace but any boost you would get at running back, which is debateable, is offset by your tight end woes. gates is at his most underwhelming this year, and he probly doesnt have much left in the tank left anyway. whereas graham is seemingly a lock for years to come, i think hes too valuable to give up for not much in return