HELP!! Trade Newton and Maclin for E. Manning and Witten?

[kraemera]

Should I trade Cam Newton and Jeremy Maclin for Eli Manning and Jason Witten??

My Roster:
QB Cam Newton, Carson Palmer
RB Doug Martin, Trent Richardson, Alex Green, Rishard Mendenhall
WR Demaryius Thomas, Roddy White, Jeremy Maclin, Titus Young
TE J. Tamme

His Roster
QB: Eli Manning, Joe Flacco
RB Adrian Peterson, Ray Rice, Michael Turner
WR Vincent Jackson, Kendall Wright, M. Crabtree

I need better production at QB and TE, but I am worried about losing too much in this deal. Any thoughts? Please!! Should I trade for others like Turner?

[kraemera]

BUMP HELP

[KK_Cowboy]

I know you need some help at TE, but I am not sure this trade is the best way to get it. Who do you got for TE's on the WW?

[kraemera]

On the WW, is Pitta, Rudolph, M. Lewis, Dwayne Allen, Clark, Fleener..really not much

[KK_Cowboy]

I took another look at this (considering the lack of TE's on the wire) and although I don't really like trading Cam, I think you can actually make the Eli and Palmer rotation work. Especially since Palmer plays the Saints on Eli's bye week. Given what you need and after digging a little deeper, I would say pull the trigger on this.

[kraemera]

Do you think I should add Roddy instead of Maclin and try to get Michael Turner?

[KK_Cowboy]

Nah I think you are fine for RB and WR.

[kraemera]

K Thanks!

[kraemera]

Anyone else have any thoughts on this trade?