Trade my Roddy for Richardson or Mathews? WHIR!

[trumpettar]

I have a trade offer out for Richardson/Santana Moss for my Roddy and Fred Jackson (Santana Moss just thrown in for league more likely to approve).

Just after sending this out, I got a request that I give up Roddy and get Mathews and Lloyd.

Whichever RB I get will be my 1 Keeper for next year. Should I wait for response for TRich trade or accept the Mathews one before he cancels?

Please leave link!

[nyr199435]

Jeez that's tough. The Mathews one is really good value for Roddy. I had such high hopes for Mathews but he hasn't done squat yet. Meanwhile, T-Rich is an absolute monster and will be for years to come. Obviously I would prefer the T-Rich side, but if you think the offer that's out now is in danger of being taken off the table I think you would have to do it. I only expect Mathews' value to go up the rest of the season. Many so-called fantasy "experts" had Mathews pegged as a top 5 RB this season.

Basically it comes down to two questions:
1) Do you think the T-Rich deal has a reasonably good shot of getting done?
2) Do you think the Mathews/Lloyd owner will really take that off the table if you don't act soon?

[BravesGuy]

If you are a longshot to win this year take the Richardson deal. He would be a solid keeper.
That Matthews deal is a good one too. He could easily turn it around and give you a boost at RB. Lloyd is a drop off from Roddy, but he still is a pretty solid option.

[Aintdatapeach]

I would def take that Richardson deal if it's still on the table. Mathews one isn't bad either if you can't get the other.

[WhoDatRebs]

With this being a keeper league, I would be all over T Rich. He's the guy there in Cle and while Roddy will be tough to give up, the ball is spread around a lot more in ATL than it is in Cle. T Rich will be a beast for years to come.

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=528969

[goose in my step]

since this is a keeper i def want trich. although both offers are pretty good

help:http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=528971&p=3497102#p3497102

[trumpettar]

woot I got both. Had to get rid of Roddy, DMC, and VJAX but in the end got Mathews, Richardson, Santana Moss, and B Lloyd. Not bad since I get a likely keeper with Richardson, or can choose Mathews if he becomes a badass. Thanks for help all!

[jcwooddy]

I would wait for TRich.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=529029