Charles and Big Ben for Brady and Mcgahee?

[Ryanj37]

Hey guys,

New to this forum, it looks really good so far. Got a trade question for you guys, happy to help in return if links are provided.

Standard scoring Yahoo 10 team league.

My team:

QB: Big Ben (E. Manning)
RB: Adrian Petersen, Jamaal Charles (Jonothan Stewart, Pieere Thomas, Beanie Wells)
WR: Nelson, Fitzgerald, Coulston (Heyward-bey, Broyles)
TE: Graham

My team is 7-2 and a pretty good shot to win the league.

Does the trade in the title make my team better? Brady is signifcantly better then either Big ben or eli and with the way KC's offense is going Mcgahee looks pretty comparable to Charles in production going forward.

Looking forward to reading your responses!

[mike11]

Good one sided trade for you. i would never accept that trade. Brady>big ben Mcgahee>charles and its not even close

[woowoo crew]

yes, it certainly makes your team better; pretty much a lock to win it all. if you can do it, then do it. good luck!

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=529018

[Ryanj37]

Good one sided trade for you. i would never accept that trade. Brady>big ben Mcgahee>charles and its not even close

You really think mcgahee > Charles? Im a big Charles believer but you might be right if your thinking that KC's horrendous coaching and offense will continue to cripple charles.

Thanks for your reply.