Trading RG3? WHIR

[dem warriors]

Haven't been on here in ages, but looking for some advice. 12 team PPR league, non-keeper, 1QB, 2WR, 2RB, 1TE, 1 Flex, 1K, 1DEF
I'm currently in 2nd.

Was offered this:

I give: RG3, Antonio Gates, Stevie Johnson, and SF Defense
I get: Matt Stafford, Trent Richardson, Dustin Keller, and Miami Defense

My team currently:

QB:RG3, Alex Smith
WR: Wes Welker, Torrey Smith, Stevie Johnson, Ryan Broyles
RB: Ray Rice, Darren Sproles, Andre Brown, Isaac Redman, Rashard Mendenhall
TE: Antonio Gates, Aaron Hernandez
K: Legatron
Def: SF

Thoughts?

[trumpettar]

thanks for the help with mine.

eeeeeek this is a tough one. the only reason I would not do this is that trent has a rough schedule coming up (Dallas, Den, Pit twice) and RG3 could give you more points than trent and stafford combined.

[Birdem]

no way the only player that makes this interesting is trent richardson. I dont like the other players stafford isnt as consistent than rg3. I like gates over keller. Richardson is the only better player that hes giving you in return. I sorta cancelled the defenses out.

[dem warriors]

I managed to bargain him down to this offer:

Get: Trent Richardson, Keller, Titus Young
Give: Gates, Stevie Johnson, Andre Brown

What do you all think?