Andrew Luck for Jamaal Charles? Keeper league (WHIR)

[Pengh]

A guy is throwing in the Towel and is interested in Luck. Is asking for J.Charles worth it?

PPR - 5 player keeper league.

QBs are the highest scoring players in my league - top 5 scorers are QBs.

I have Brady and drafted Luck for the future.

I have a shot at winning this year.

my RBs are

D.Murray.
CJ Spiller
Michael Bush
Ivory

we start 1 qb and start 3 rbs. also have a flex spot.

I think Luck is going to be the #1 scorer in my league in 2 years if not next year. Don't know if I should trade him away.

[Calix]

Definately dont trade Luck in a keep league for Charles. Until Charles gets on a team with a QB he is pretty much useless in my mind. Nexts year QB class is not that good in my opinion either, so Charles will not produce this year, next year, and maybe never. Except for the occasional game.

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=529524

[saemick]

Agree, honestly in a keeper league (heck even in a redraft league at this point), I'd rather have Luck than Charles. if he's dead set on Luck, ask for more.

Until Charles goes to a different team, or KC completely overhauls their coaching staff, his value wil be limited.

thanks for the help with mine

[winningallthesports]

Well youre not that solid at RB, but for a rookie QB thats shaping up to be one of the best in the league for years to come, I think you should ask for a lot more, maybe a young receiver or TE to go along with Charles.

help with mine please viewtopic.php?t=529452