Trade Aaron Hernandez for Ryan Mathews? WHIR

[handslikesecrets]

Do I trade Aaron Hernandez (and Rashad Jennings, who I have no use for) for Ryan Mathews?

[Mean One]

If you are desperately hurting at the RB position and you have a good TE filling in for Hernandez I might consider the trade as is. Otherwise you are giving up a top 5 TE for a top 25 RB that is currently losing touches to a 30-yr old RB.

[handslikesecrets]

I have Greg Olsen as my backup TE.

[Mean One]

Olsen is serviceable till Hernandez returns, then history. Post your roster.

[handslikesecrets]

It's a non-PPR, 12-team league, heads-up.
My roster is:
QB- Tom Brady
QB- Russell Wilson
RB- Jamaal Charles
RB- Benjarvus Green-Ellis
RB- DeMarco Murray
RB- Rashad Jennings
WR- Roddy White
WR- Andre Johnson
WR- Denarius Moore
WR- Brian Hartline
WR- Kenny Britt
TE- Greg Olsen
TE- Aaron Hernandez
D/ST- Seattle
D/ST- Falcons
K- Greg Zuerlein

[winningallthesports]

This is kinda tough. If Demarco Murray comes back hot, Mathews would be a flex play, and you already have 2 solid WRs in Moore and Hartline that you could put there (or even BJGE). If Murray stays unhealthy or comes back soft then Mathews could fill in your RB#2 slot. Olsens a solid backup with a relatively soft schedule, but Hernandez really cant be denied. Bottom line is I dont see you having a better team after the trade.

help with mine please viewtopic.php?t=529642