Welker for Spiller ? PPR WHIR

[DarkExile]

I put the trade through last week and it's still in review status because games were played this week.

With the injury to gronk should i still let this go through?

The guy getting hernandez has no shot of making the playoffs so I'm not worried about his team improving.

I've tried to make some other deals but I'm not even gettin acknowledgements from any other owners - so this is really the last deal I have a shot at making before the deadline in 2 days.

I guess it comes down to this.

Would you take:
1) C.J. Spiller w/ Cecil Shorts flex
2) a low end RB2 (James Starks , Vick Ballard, Mark Ingram types) w/ Wes Welker flex
option 2 leaves me with Aaron Hernandez on the bench since I have Tony G starting.... so I could only see me starting Hernandez if one of my receivers or Tony G got hurt.... our championship is played in week 16 so I shouldn't have to worry about any guys getting sat in the last game either...

Undecided now! =(

[bandoogie]

What's the rest of your team look like?

[DarkExile]

I wisely snagged Starks off the waiver wire last week and he's the lead back in GB now - I can grab Benson and stash him on my bench too

QB Stafford or Palmer (playing matchups atm)
RB1 Jamaal Charles
RB2 One of these guys (James Starks, Vick ballard,Danny Woodhead)
WR1 A.J. Green
WR2 Roddy White
Flex Welker
TE T Gonzalez
DST Broncos

BENCH - Cecil Shorts, Aaron Hernandez

[bandoogie]

Looking at your team, I'd probably go with Spiller. He's clearly better than your RB2's. You could also gamble on picking up McCoy or McGahee's backups, but no guarantee what you're going to get with them. Have you also thought about trading Tony G? What about packaging Tony&Welker for a tier 1 RB?

[petrieslastword]

So long as you can replace Welker, take the deal. Spiller is a mucyh better option for you.

Mine?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=530138