Big Trade Need Help

[BlackBocks]

I am currently 7-3 but started off 5-0. In a .5PPR league.

I have this trade proposed to me. My team is listed below.

Get: Spiller, Tony Gonzalez, Desean Jackson

Give: Gore and Roddy White.

My Team
QB: Matt Ryan
RB: T.Richardson, Gore, Sproles, M.Bush, Dwyer, Redman
WR: White, D.Thomas, James Jones, Titus Young, Blackmon
TE: Brandon Myers, Finley


Do I do this deal? Thanks.

BB

[broseph jacobs]

So I look at this and immediately discount Dwyer, Redmann, Sproles, Bush, Blackmon & Finley.

So we're looking at
This....
QB: Matt Ryan
RB: T.Richardson, Gore
WR: White, D.Thomas, James Jones, Titus Young
TE: Myers

or this...
QB: Matt Ryan
RB: T.Richardson, Spiller
WR: D.Thomas, James Jones, D. Jackson, Titus Young
TE: Gonzalez, Myers

I don't like it on the surface: you are giving away your best receiver for a very shaky one - made shakier than ever by Foles being named starter in Vick's absence. Also, you are giving up Frank Gore for CJ Spiller. I'd say that's a really close swap in a .5 PPR. And you're getting Gonzo as a throw-in, basically? Is Gonzo rated higher than Myers? I'm guessing probably. But is he somebody you need?

Bottom line: is Gonzalez enough to make up for your loss at WR? I say no! Don't do this deal.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=529797