Ugh...annoying offers/counteroffers...help! (WHIR)

[nyr199435]

Here's the team:
0.5 PPR, 2 QB league
QB: Aaron Rodgers
QB: RGIII
WR: Brandon Lloyd
WR: Torrey Smith
RB: Jamaal Charles
RB: Ryan Mathews
TE: Jimmy Graham
W/T: Randall Cobb
W/R: Titus Young
BN: MJD, Fred Jackson, Jake Locker, Pierre Garcon, Danario Alexander

I keep going back and forth with this guy in my league who traded Peyton Manning and a day later lost Roethlisberger to injury, and now he really wants RGIII or Rodgers. I thought I had a good deal in place, but when I come on here to check to make sure I should do it, he usually changes his mind and cancels the offer before I get an answer.

Anyway, just the latest in a series of back-and-forths between me and this guy:
I give: RGIII, Brandon Lloyd
I get: Joe Flacco, Calvin Johnson

Do I do this? I was originally going to get Palmer/Martin/Megatron for RGIII/Mathews/Lloyd, but he took that off the table in the time it took me to ask about it on this board.

Anyway, thanks and leave a link!!

[DarkExile]

Can you post who else he has on his team? I don't like the existing deal for you (you're not getting enough) but since he's in desperation mode you should be able to make something happen

[donkquixote]

I'm OK with it. Not thrilled with Flacco but you have Locker as a wildcard.

viewtopic.php?t=529799

[nyr199435]

His team:
QB: Palmer
QB: Flacco
WR: Megatron
WR: Welker
RB: Martin
RB: T-Rich
TE: Pettigrew
W/T: Fitzgerald
W/R: Denarius Moore
BN: Boldin, Donald Brown, Finley, Jason Campbell,

[murphysxm]

I would MUCH rather have Palmer than Flacco. Make it Torrey and RGIII for Palmer and Megatron. Gives him and Flacco/Smith combo and you basically break even at QB and get huge upgrade at WR

[DarkExile]

Palmer has a better schedule coming up than Flacco (plus he's FAR more consistent)

I'd try and get that first trade he offered as that benefits you the most:
RG3/Lloyd/Matthews
Palmer/Megatron/Martin

if he won't go for that I'd say any trade involving RG3 you need to get Palmer in return and work your way down from there.

So something like

RG3/Matthews/Lloyd
for
Palmer/TRicharson/WelkerOrFitz

I liked T richs schedule over Martins for the rest of the year - T Rich gets pit twice but Martin gets Atl twice, Denver and NO (which could turn into a shootout even with their lousy D)

Megatron has a hard schedule coming up - GB twice, houston, atl and chicago week 17 - gross