I'm in 2nd place at 7-3 in a 12 team, h2h, standard, non-ppr, 6pt/td Start - 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1flex, 1te, 1td, 1pk QB: Tannehill RB: Forte, Charles WR: Calvin, Marshall, Wayne TE: Jimmy Graham FX: Redman PK: Gould TD: Dolphins
No way I'd trade Marshall. Maybe Thomas (although I don't see him on your roster). The question is, how long is Ben going to be out? If he comes back in 2 weeks, it will be a bad trade for you. If he's out many weeks, you should make the trade. None of us know the answer to that, but I'd make the trade for Thomas because you aren't going to win in the playoffs with Tannehill as your QB.
aqr135 wrote:No way I'd trade Marshall. Maybe Thomas (although I don't see him on your roster). The question is, how long is Ben going to be out? If he comes back in 2 weeks, it will be a bad trade for you. If he's out many weeks, you should make the trade. None of us know the answer to that, but I'd make the trade for Thomas because you aren't going to win in the playoffs with Tannehill as your QB.
It would be either Marshall or Megatron for Palmer and Maclin
Oh, okay, it said D Thomas at first. I wouldn't make the trade. You'll be able to make the trade in a week or two if Ben is still out and you're already in a good spot for the playoff, but I still wouldn't give up either of those guys. What other QBs are on the wire?
aqr135 wrote:Oh, okay, it said D Thomas at first. I wouldn't make the trade. You'll be able to make the trade in a week or two if Ben is still out and you're already in a good spot for the playoff, but I still wouldn't give up either of those guys. What other QBs are on the wire?
Right, forgot about the deadline. Bradford has more consistent numbers and the STL offense is playing well right now. You could pick him up in addition to Tannehill and mix-and-match until Ben gets back. If you don't want to risk being without a good QB for the playoffs, I'd try to make a different deal, either for a better QB or for a lesser receiver. I think you're giving up too much, especially because you start 3 WRs.
aqr135 wrote:Right, forgot about the deadline. Bradford has more consistent numbers and the STL offense is playing well right now. You could pick him up in addition to Tannehill and mix-and-match until Ben gets back. If you don't want to risk being without a good QB for the playoffs, I'd try to make a different deal, either for a better QB or for a lesser receiver. I think you're giving up too much, especially because you start 3 WRs.
How about I trade Jimmy Graham for Palmer and Olsen
Give us the other guy's team, makes it easier to help with trades. The one thing i would say is that assuming DMC comes back he has an easy schedule to end the year, if he gets it going you will probably use him/charles/forte in the playoffs meaning you need only 2 receivers. If thats the case then the trade isnt quite as bad, although it kills your depth a bit. I wish the guy in my league that lost Vick would be this eager, i offered him Cam and Reggie Bush for Spiller and he thought i was nuts.
Would the guy take DMC for Palmer straight up? You could start Forte/Charles and your 3 receivers and not sweat out DMC's injury the rest of the year. The other guy will probabyl do it since Palmer is just going to rot on his bench the rest of the year and it gives him a lottery ticket
mycuccismells wrote:Give us the other guy's team, makes it easier to help with trades. The one thing i would say is that assuming DMC comes back he has an easy schedule to end the year, if he gets it going you will probably use him/charles/forte in the playoffs meaning you need only 2 receivers. If thats the case then the trade isnt quite as bad, although it kills your depth a bit. I wish the guy in my league that lost Vick would be this eager, i offered him Cam and Reggie Bush for Spiller and he thought i was nuts.
Would the guy take DMC for Palmer straight up? You could start Forte/Charles and your 3 receivers and not sweat out DMC's injury the rest of the year. The other guy will probabyl do it since Palmer is just going to rot on his bench the rest of the year and it gives him a lottery ticket
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by ob187 » Thu Nov 15, 2012 3:26 pm 
