2 trades: RG3/Lynch v Rogers/McCoy and Spiller v Jamal WHIR

[teach42]

10 team, non PPR. 1QB 2RB 2WR 1TE 1Flex. $50 auction, if I break the cap next year my auction budget will be around $43, and any of these trades will likely break the cap for me

QB: P Manning / RG3
RB: Lynch / MJD / Turner / Spiller
WR: Cruz / Colston / Wallace / Cobb / Maclin / Amendola
TE: Gonzalez

Been offered Rogers and McCoy in exchange for Lynch and RG3.

Also offered Jamal Charles for Spiller.

Would you do either? Both? Trying to put together a playoff run but neither of these give me the RB3 that I desperately need since MJD went down.

Maybe do the Rogers trade and then try to trade off Manning?

[TheBeaker]

I dont see how either of those trades is worth it. I keep hearing MJD is supposed to be back next week or the week after. To be honest what i might try and do is just trade one of your QBs for a stud RB straight up? What does the guy who has Ben Roethlisburger have at RB and a what does he have for a backup QB? Thats the type of trade that makes more sense to me. The Rodgers trade has some merrit, especially if you can get a good return on Peyton. I like lynch better as you RB though.

[babiiverson]

Rogers trade is a no brainer

Personally I'd do the Charles trade only because Spiller will revert back to a RRBC once FJax is back.

viewtopic.php?t=529459

[PatriotsGirl]

I wouldn't do either trade. I think RGIII will be coming back, especially with Vick out this week for their game Sunday. I like Rodgers a lot but as TheBeaker said, Lynch is a great RB. I like Spiller too and wouldn't trade him away now.

[Indibuck]

I would pass on both trades, especially if they hurt you in next year's auction.

[teach42]

One last thought. The guy with Jamal Charles is bailing on the season. He may be willing to 'throw in' Decker.

So would you take Decker + Jamal for Spiller?