Who did you vastly overrate on your team?

[Papa Deuce]

Aaron Rodgers. Was my pick in the first round. Picked up Peyton Manning much later as a backup, and in retrospect he would have carried my team just fine over Rodgers (especially the last 4 weeks, Manning has averaged 10 more ppg over that strech), and I would have been stronger at RB or WR with that 1st round pick. Oh well.

I kept him. If he put up last year's numbers to date, I am in 1st place. But, alas, I am tied for 2nd. And likely can't win the league.

[Sixxgunn]

Jamaal Charles. If he had a coach that knew his ass from a hole in the ground, he easily could have finished in the top three at the position. Instead, after several weeks of 3 pts or so, I traded him for Ridley...just as Ridley hit his slow down and Charles stepped it up.

[kodadog]

Where do I start:
D Bowe(5th)- Bad coaching, bad QB's, bad everything after week 4.
V Davis(6th)- I think they forgot he is on the field
DMC(2nd)- I know, my fault but when healthy last year he was good, new coaching new offense scheme.
D Jackson(8th)- Vick couldn't hold onto the ball.
S Greene(7th)- The Jets, the most dysfunctional team in the NFL
R Jennings(12th)- picked him up late in the draft (in case MJD didn't play), he crapped the bed when given the chance
P Garcon(10th)- foot injury didn't help
So there is 7 of my 14 picks that I haven't played since the beginning of the season. Luckily I had A Rodgers, D Martin, Sea/Cinci Def, B Marshall and picked up Spiller, Alexander, and Shorts. Somehow made it to the championship game(smoke and mirrors with some luck).

[LMack]

Overrated Rodgers, McFadden, Murray

Underrated Lynch, Peterson, Gore, and Gonzalez.

Such is life

[Papa Deuce]

LOL, I can't believe that Brandon Marshall is the #1 WR in my league.... yeah, I knew about Cutler and him, but I think Cutler STINKS.... So I guess I vastly underrated Marshall. There is something wrong when Brandon Marshall is better than Calvin Johnson under any circumstances, LOL.

BTW, injuries aside, I think LeSean McCoys issues were more of a problem created by the Eagles, and specifically Andy Reid's coaching philosophies. He may not have been as good as last year, but I think McCoy is still a top 10 back with the right coach.

I can't wait to see Reid in San Diego next year with Rivers.