Shorts or Garcon

[Coltsfan1201]

Shorts or Garcon
Who to start in my WR3?
1 pt PPR, 1 pt per 15 yds/rec

[zjk924]

That's tricky. Garcon is the better WR, and RG3 is the better QB throwing at him, but Giants pass-rush is pretty lethal. Then again, it's pretty clearly Justin Blackmon is the go-to guy for Chad Henne now, so even though Buffalo defense sucks, I wouldn't count on Short to do too much.

I'd probably go with Garcon.


viewtopic.php?f=19&t=530734&p=3504965#p3504965

[Coltsfan1201]

Blackmon isn't the go to guy from what I have seen. Which is why I'm having problems with this choice.

[zjk924]

Yeah, I mean there's a lot of risk both ways- Garcon/RG3 is the better pairing, but Giants pash-rush looked sick against Rodgers. But I still feel like they have more upside.

[soju808]

I'd go with Shorts. He's been very consistent for the past 4 weeks. Keep him in!

viewtopic.php?t=530779

[urbancommando]

Garcon is injury prone and shorts has shown week in and week out he can play ball

Shorts gets my vote

[prince_45243]

I think I'd go with Shorts as well. He's had 3 solid games in a row including a good game against Houston. BUF looks to be about the same caliber of a defense as IND or TEN where he broke a hundred yards and a score. Garcon did have a good game last week vs DAL but nothing much against PHI or earlier ATL or TB.

Good luck!

[wildsau]

Tough one but I agree on the Giants passing rush and the far easier matchup for Shorts and would go for him.

viewtopic.php?t=530811