Aaron Rodgers or Peyton Manning? WHIR

[soju808]

I'm fed up with Aaron Rodgers and his inconsistency. I'm pretty much considering shutting him down for the rest of the season in favor of Peyton Manning who's been way more consistent. Please convince me why I should start Rodgers over Manning. WHIR

Aaron Rodgers vs Min
Peyton Manning vs Tampa

[11stever11]

I think it is a coin flip, but I prefer Rodgers this week with Jennings coming back.

[goodwidp]

I agree with 11stever11 that it's pretty much a coin-flip decision. They're pretty much the #'s 1 and 2 QBs this week and they both have their huge potential. I guess if I had to choose, I'd go with Manning as he has a great matchup vs a very weak Bucs pass D. Either way you really can't go wrong.

Thanks for your help with mine.

[woowoo crew]

No convincing needed. I'd start Peyton. TB has allowed 5 QBs to throw for 300 plus yards; 1 to throw for over 400; and 1 to throw for over 500 yds! The 500 yarder was Eli, so I'd certainly play Peyton over Rodgers. I do think Rodgers will have a bounce back game after the embarrassing one GB just had. But that wouldn't deter me from playing Peyton!

Help me please: viewtopic.php?f=19&t=530796

[tindo]

I like Rodgers with Jennings coming back ant it being against MIN who the packers love playing dominator to.

Help Please?! viewtopic.php?t=530837