I dropped Amendola for Givens in both my leagues. Don't get into the "what if" topics, you will mess yourself up. The playoffs is starting in most formats and you have to play for that week. Amendola is out this week and even though he is the guy in St. Louis, I can't afford having him on my roster if I am not using him this week or his status is uncertain. Pick him up if he is available. He is clearly the main target in St. Louis right now.
ESPN PPR League (2QB, 2RB, 3 WR, TE, FLEX, D/ST, K)
QB - P. Manning, RGIII, Freeman
RB - AP, A. Morris, Steven Jax, B. Brown
WR - A.J., D. Moore, Crabtree, M. Williams, Amendola
TE - Daniels, Rudolph, Myers
DEF - Patriots
K - Dawson