You have some good choices here but I like the 3 that you are leaning towards.
Deangelo - he's their 2nd RB on that team behind Cam. Yes, he does have TD's the past 2 weeks but they're both off of screens which is a little bit of a fluke and they caught an aggresive D at the right time. And you know he's not going to get any carries inside the 5 yard line, those are going to Tolbert. Bench'em
McCoy - there's just too many question marks here. You gotta bench'em. Even when he was healthy he wasn't having a GREAT season like he did last year, he's been doing just OK. In his last 6 games when he was healthy he averaged exactly 16 carries per game, he only broke 100 yards once in those 6 games, in the other 5 games he averaged 3.2 yds / carry. Also, only 1 TD in those 6 games. Philly is just not the same this year.
Then basically by process of elimination Reggie, Decker, and Leshoure are your starters and I would feel confident about starting all 3 of these guys. Not of them are exactly head scratchers. Good Luck!
Help with mine? Thanksviewtopic.php?t=532796