New UPDATE: OK, so I offered TRIch + Cobb + Garcon, he wasn't really feeling it. THEN I offered TRich + DT + Blackmon or Hilton for AP and Welker. He said he is going to give it serious thought. He's understandably a bit hesitant b/c it's AP. He also mentioned that he's not crazy about DT's boom-or-bust style (7 pts vs dallas).
Do you think I should go w/ a counter if he rejects? What would you give?
UPDATE: Ok, so looks like there are a few options for an initial offer 1) Martin + Garcon for AP (less likely he'll accept IMO) 2) Martin + D Thomas for AP 3) TRich + Cobb + Garcon for AP 4) TRich + D Thomas + Blackmon or Hilton(?) for AP + Welker Which one would be your FIRST offer?
Idk if he's willing, but I think he's open to offers
His team: QB Aaron Rodgers, Cutler WR welker , Eric Decker, VJax, Nate Washington, D. Moore RB Adrian Peterson, DeMarco Murray,F. Jackson, B. Jacobs TE Tony Gonzalez, Jordan Cameron
I've proposed Cobb + TRich for AP (I know it's pretty low) He pondered it for a bit, but was reluctant b/c AP is "guaranteed 20"
He wants WRs, and I assume not to lose all his RB depth.
What would you be willing to package? Or should I target Murray? Or is he not worth it?
Last edited by j diggs on Sat Oct 12, 2013 6:49 pm, edited 4 times in total.
Record: 3-3 10-team, .25 PPR Start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1W/R/T, 1K, 1D QB: Brady RB: Martin, Foster, T. Richardson, SJax WR: D. Thomas, B. Marshall, R. Cobb, Garcon, Gordon, Blackmon, TY Hilton TE: J. Thomas Def: NYJ K: J. Tucker
Yeah, I think so. If he doesn't bite at that, try Martin and Cobb. Cobb has a little better equity in his name than Garcon, so this could be seen as "upping" your offer. Truth be told, I'd rather have Garcon going forward--maybe offer Cobb first if you feel the same way?
That's too much, IMO, at least to start. Start out a little lower on the WR side of things rather than trotting out your big guns from the get-go. I'm very on the fence re: whether DT + Martin is a good deal, but given your WR depth I'd lean yes.
I'd give him Demaryus Thomas, and TRich, AND one of your lesser WRs
FOR: Welker, and AP
He already has two Broncos studs WR, but would take Demaryus over those two, however Welker in the long run will prove equally as valuable or more, and he'd willingly give you AP- the best!!! You get Top notch RB, and WR.
If you mean Steven Jackson by "jax"- try him before TRich. Then go for that!
I find 2 for 1s,,, or 3 for 2s are enticing, deceiving, and get it done!
Help me... its actually a veto trade question in commish and this forum