I've got pretty much the same decision.
Edelman looked awful last week. Yes, I know the conditions were terrible. But he had balls bouncing off his chest left and right.
He basically has no red zone appeal. His upside is extremely limited. Now Amendola is back. Plus, the matchup is not great. Plus, NE only chance is to play ball control and try to keep Brees from scoring 50 pts. I just have a bad feeling about Edelman.
However, he is still pretty safe. K. Allen looks great. But, he is still pretty unproven. With Edelman, you are pretty much guaranteed 8-10 pts. at minimum. With Allen, the floor is lower and the ceiling is higher.
My gut says K. Allen has the better day. But, if I need 8-10 and little risk, I'd go Edelman even after my rant.viewtopic.php?f=19&t=541586