KingGhidra wrote:Sorry I forgot a few. Namely McAllister, Alexander and Henry. After that it becomes iffy with age & injuries (Holmes/Faulk/Davis). Ricky I guess, but he may have seen his better days already with so many carries the last two years ala Eddie George.
So that adds 3 more definites to my list, which makes him 11th overall. I definitely wouldn't take Barber(fumblitis) or CMart(salary cap) over Dillon if I were the GM of an NFL franchise. Dom Davis and Rudi are in limbo right now. Give me a full season of work and let me see what they can really do.
You do know that Dillon is about the same age as Holmes/Faulk/Davis right? Dillon is going to be 30 this year as is Davis, Faulk and Holmes are both going to be 31. So if your going to hold that against them hold it against him as well. Anyhow, all three are much more talented than Dillon.
CMart is the better RB, that's what I'm talking about.....not the salary cap.
Tiki I would take because he can actually catch a pass out of the backfield, something Dillon never could.....his fumbles really hurt, but I think he has more long-term potential than Dillon.
Ricky I'm kind of acting on faith that he will recover, but even in what is considered a down year he managed more yards from scrimmage than Dillon ever has.
Rudi has proved to be the better runner than Dillon in Cincy this year. Dominick looks like the best rookie RB out there.
Anyhow based on your rankings he is anywhere from the 11th - 17th best RB right now......not far from my original swag of 15-20th best.