Worse call, Martz or Sherman?

[KingGhidra]

You Green Bay apologists are a special breed of homers. Now that you lost blame the Coach, the refs anybody.....
How bout the STUPID throw Favre made in OT
Like GB vs STL is a better game.
you guys make me throw up
I am so glad GB is out they really SUCK

buddy, I would rather see the greatest show on turf versus Ahman and Favre than McNabb and his band of driftwood versus a Davisless Carolina team..

I would rather see the best two teams in the NFC, and that's what I have.

The Guest is right, the GB fans need to quit whining.

That figures coming from a Seahawk fan.

Truth is, Green Bay had the game in their hands and they gave it away 3x in the last 5 mins of the game. A 4th & 1 they didnt try to convert, a 4th & 26 they let the Eagles convert and that godawful pass Favre threw in OT.

[Transmogrifier]

yeah well, we'll see how exciting the superbowl is with Carolina or Philly in it. For the record, I'm a Seahawks fan.

I'd have to say that McNabb is one of the most exciting players in football. I love watching him scramble and make those quick throws, a la to Pinkston in the corner.

[Redskins Win]

I don't think you can say one is worse than the other, because they were both boneheaded coaching decesions.

[Buckychudd]

Sherman's call was a vote of confidence in his D.

Martz's call was a vote of no confidence in his O.

Not trusting your team not to screw up is the worse call.

[slowkidz]

Sherman's call was a vote of confidence in his D.

Martz's call was a vote of no confidence in his O.

Not trusting your team not to screw up is the worse call.

exactly.

[DUKE]

yeah well, we'll see how exciting the superbowl is with Carolina or Philly in it. For the record, I'm a Seahawks fan.

Mcnabb has always been pretty exciting, and i personally enjoy watching Carolina play. If you haven't thought they were enjoyable throughout these playoffs, i wonder how you could call yourself a football fan.

[KingGhidra]

Sherman's call was a vote of confidence in his D.

Martz's call was a vote of no confidence in his O.

Not trusting your team not to screw up is the worse call.

Of course the only thing is. If he had confidence in his D, he should've went for it. There is no upside to punting. If you go for it, the upside is an NFC Championship game.

[TTTBone]

Sherman's call was a vote of confidence in his D.

Martz's call was a vote of no confidence in his O.

Not trusting your team not to screw up is the worse call.

I disagreed with Sherman's call, but I wouldn't go so far as to call it a boneheaded move. Martz on the other hand...
Sherman
Martz

[Buckychudd]

Sherman's call was a vote of confidence in his D.

Martz's call was a vote of no confidence in his O.

Not trusting your team not to screw up is the worse call.

Of course the only thing is. If he had confidence in his D, he should've went for it. There is no upside to punting. If you go for it, the upside is an NFC Championship game.

I didn't say it was a good call, just better than Martz's. Personally, I think they would have won the game if they had gone for it.

[KingGhidra]

Sherman's call was a vote of confidence in his D.

Martz's call was a vote of no confidence in his O.

Not trusting your team not to screw up is the worse call.

Of course the only thing is. If he had confidence in his D, he should've went for it. There is no upside to punting. If you go for it, the upside is an NFC Championship game.

I didn't say it was a good call, just better than Martz's. Personally, I think they would have won the game if they had gone for it.

Every Eagles fan let out a sigh of relief when that punting unit came on, that's for sure.