E.George or F.Taylor in week 1...

[MN Rube]

Should I start Eddie George at home VS Philly
or
Fred Taylor at home VS Indy

I'm also planing on starting S.McNair and D.Mason...is it bad to start 3 players from the same team if i start George? whould i get killed if TEN had a bad game?!?!

[trentvaughn]

I would certainly start Eddie George. He looks like the back of the old days recently. He's an every week starter. And don't feel bad about starting three players from a team. When the QB hooks up with either of them for a TD, you'll be twice as happy.

Tretvaughn

[MN Rube]

I started to second guess my choice of E.george when I saw that Fred Taylor was going against Indy's defense...plus I don't know how many games Taylor will actually start this year before he gets hurt!

thanks for the help!

[DraftDodger]

Most leagues start 2 RBs or 1 and a Flex ... if your's does ... who are you starting ahead of either of these guys? Do you have Faulk, Green, or A-Train or something too?

[MN Rube]

yeah, my other RB is Faulk...
so i'm trying to decide if I should start George or F.Taylor with him.

[SolarfluX]

I'd play Taylor against the suspect IND defense; you might as well get some value out of him before he gets injured. Yes, I know Dungy has improved the D on paper, but they will have to show what they can do on the field.

I don't think George will do all that great against a good D like Philly. Even though trentvaughn thinks their run D is weak, they shut down the A-Train in the playoffs last year. They'll be able to handle George by stacking the line and forcing McNair to throw to your boy Mason.