Onterrio Smith, Chris Brown or DeShaun Foster, who is better

[NittanyLions]

10 people in our league. We start 2 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, TE, K, plus 6 defensive players, with the defensive and rookie drafts being held seperately, and 25 man total rosters, and we can keep up to 20 each year.

GEEZ! these guys are available? how do i get in ur league?

[VHawk15]

Even though I think Chris Brown might be talented, you definitely have to go with DeShaun.

[moochman]

I like Onterrio but I wouldn't draft him.

Who has kidnapped Zimm? lol. With Bennet's frailty exposed last year, the explosive nature of the Vikes O, and the sieve-like tendencies of their D there will be plenty of FF points for Smith. And you have to like the show Foster put on in the playoffs. Brown is more of a risk. I'd rate them:
1) Smith
2) Foster
3) Brown

[Gunslinger]

I like Foster, but you can't go wrong with any of those guys in round 12!

I agree, that's amazing that they are all there. I'm wondering what is wrong with the Bennett, George, and Davis owners. They all seem to be prime trade targets.

[deftdelivery]

Deshaun Foster..cos of their great O-line.

Minnesota's o-line is better than carolina's. Go with SOD 03

Wait...You're saying Onterrio Smith?
Wow...that's so unorthodox of you man!

[awwchrist]

A team having a better O-line is not a reason to select a back-up RB over another in a dynasty draft.

Eddie George retiring is.

Or DeShaun Foster showing he's the best backup RB in the NFL is.

[Purple_Pride]

id rate them Foster, smith then Brown. though Smith does have a chance of becoming the starter this year.

[M_Zimm_ffc]

I like Onterrio but I wouldn't draft him.

Who has kidnapped Zimm? lol. With Bennet's frailty exposed last year, the explosive nature of the Vikes O, and the sieve-like tendencies of their D there will be plenty of FF points for Smith. And you have to like the show Foster put on in the playoffs. Brown is more of a risk. I'd rate them:
1) Smith
2) Foster
3) Brown

I'll tel ya why...I've seen way too many Vikings games. I have seen the rbbc first-hand. There is no way we are going to trade Bennett. He is still very young and very good. There is talk that he may go to the Olympic trials this year just to see where he places. In other words, he's fast. There is no reason we should getrid of Bennett and he earned the starting spot. He was second in rishing yards three years ago, behind Edge. With oster projected to get more carries and Eddie probably on his way out I would take one of them.

[The Great Gambini]

I think Bennett realizes that if he gets hurt again, he may never get the job back, so I think he will start taking better care of himself and prevent further injury. This will lead to RBBC or a backup role for Onterrio for the next few years. I think you go with Foster, Brown, then Smith.

[moochman]

Alls I'm saying, Zimm, is that the Vikes have proven that they will put points year after year, the Panthers may fall on thier face next year. Both have a problem with being young (and so cheap) and playing behind higher priced vets. Bennet is more fragile than Davis, so my tie-breaker vote goes to Smith.