Best QB All Time

[awwchrist]

Gannon?



Warner?

I'm speechless.

Gotta be the guest-o's he had for breakfast

hahaha

Can I use that? Guest-o's. Nice.

[5XCowboys22]

1. Joe Montana
2. Johnny Unitas
3. Terry Bradshaw
4. Roger Staubach
5. Bart Starr
6. Troy Aikman
7. Dan Marino
8. Steve Young
9. Brett Favre
10.Joe Namath

[IronMike420]

1)Unitas
2)Graham
3)Montana
4)Marino
5)Elway
6)Farve
I don't think Bradshaw is better than any of these guys but you
gotta give it to him for leading his team to 4 Superbowl trophies

[Vikes_Fan2823]

Where is the love for Fran Tarkenton? He is easily Top 10 matierial.

NFL's all-time leader in career passes attempted (6,467), career passes completed (3,686), career yards gained (47,003), career touchdown passes (342) and career rushing yards by a quarterback (2,548)

Montana
Naimath
Tarkenton
Bradshaw
Unitas

[Poobah]

Where is the love for Fran Tarkenton? He is easily Top 10 matierial.

NFL's all-time leader in career passes attempted (6,467), career passes completed (3,686), career yards gained (47,003), career touchdown passes (342) and career rushing yards by a quarterback (2,548)

Montana
Naimath
Tarkenton
Bradshaw
Unitas

Um, reading a book from the early 80's? How many of those records doesn't he hold now, Mr. Homer?

[CC]

Why does Namath keep getting props? So overrated. The man threw more INTs than TDs in his career, the only reason he gets credit is because he predicted the SB win.

[SwingtheSpiral]

1- Farve
2- Montana
3- Unitas
4- Young
5- Tarkenton
6- Elway
7- Marino
8- Star
9- Aikman
10- Bradshaw

[stomperrob]

Why does Namath keep getting props? So overrated. The man threw more INTs than TDs in his career, the only reason he gets credit is because he predicted the SB win.

Yeh Namath isn't one of the all-time greats, just colorful. And the reason he gets so much credit isn't for predicting the win, it's the fact that he actually won the game after the AFL stunk in the first two Super Bowls - he proved the AFL could compete and his victory as much as anything else led to the merger of the two leagues.

[stomperrob]

1- Farve

It's "Favre" (it's only pronounced "Farve")

[Jownzin]

Jesum - NOBODY has even mentioned Warren Moon?

Guy would hold a few records himself if you count his CFL stats with his NFL stats. Sure he had a few (really) dissapointing playoff losses, but he's maybe the best quarterback to never make it to the Superbowl (probably was) and was a hell of a player.

Perhaps if the Oilers were still a franchise, people might throw his name around more often.

I'd have to say my personal pick of a top 5 would be....

Dan Marino: Guy rarely had talent around him and made some players better than they might of been elsewhere. Set records in a ton of cagegories...that wasn't on accident.

Montana: He was good no doubt, but how much of this is credited to the fact he had Jerry Rice and John Taylor, Roger Craig, D anchored by Ronnie Lott, etc....?

Favre: Similar to Marino, but had a bit better talent. As tough as any of the old school QB's, and a better passer.

Elway: Ok, who else would you want with 2 min left to go in the game?

Moon: Underrated. This guy had a career that put up numbers that rivaled anyone here.

Steve Young needs mention too. Wojnder what he could have done over a career not partialy stuck in Montana's shadow.