Early 2004 Player Rankings (April)

[pmac_03]

2. Stephen Davis in the top 10, I would put him after Faulk, Dom Davis, Barlow, Henry, and Rudi.

Yeah, I agree. Davis is aging and might have to split carries, I don't see him ahead of the RB's listed above.

foster proved in the playoffs he is a gamer, that had to be the highlight of the game for me to see him break that TD run off, and the greatest play (besides the 4th and 24 pass) was his first TD run vs the eagles, fighting through the tackles, that was amazing i love foster, and he will do damage to davis time i thnk and hope, he has proved he can play.

[Str8 Pimpin-Vikings]

I found these decisions perplexing.

1. McNair over McNabb and Vick?
2. Stephen Davis in the top 10, I would put him after Faulk, Dom Davis, Barlow, Henry, and Rudi.
3. Holt as old, and Derrick Mason in the top 10.

Everything else seems good.

Those were the same exact things i were asking myself but other then that there preatty good

[Acme Rockets]

i wouldnt call torry holt "old". hes only what, 27?

Yeah, he's about the same age as Moss and younger than T.O. and Harrison...

Heheh ... my first thought too.

I would put Harrison above Holt.

However, unlike the others, I agree with putting S. Alexander below Ricky.

[pmac_03]

^"I would put Harrison above Holt.

However, unlike the others, I agree with putting S. Alexander below Ricky."

i agree, but the issue with alexander and ricky is tough, ricky has no where to run, shuandra has a good team, though that may change with the new additions to miamis line and boston hopefully getting that extra man out of the box.. but its tricky.

[TheHeat24]

The only part I see a little problem with is the WR rankings... I cant exactly remeber who you had where but it seemed kind of off tonight...

[FF Newbie]

Your rankings are fine, but frankly anyone can come up with a top-10 in each category and every list would look almost the same. The key is ranking the guys from 11-30, IMO, especially amongst RB and WR.

[pmac_03]

Your rankings are fine, but frankly anyone can come up with a top-10 in each category and every list would look almost the same. The key is ranking the guys from 11-30, IMO, especially amongst RB and WR.

ditto

[Carolina Culpepper]

Hard for me to find too much wrong with your picks when you have both Daunte and Moss as the tops at their positions. One thing threw me though, under Holt you said he was old..... He is actually very young, only in his fifth or sixth year in the league.

[LT2004]

why are you guys so high on foster this year? Do you realize that he only averaged 3.8 ypc last year?

[CC]

Did you see him in the playoffs?