Top QB's for 2004

[Mookie4ever]

I think he'll make an increidble backup, but only a fair starter. Garcia had a bad year last year by most reviews and still put up good fantasy number totals. However, in Cleveland, he'll have a lot less to work with. Though conversely, I expect CLE will fall behind often this year, leading to more passing plays.

If Morgan or Davis steps up this year (not counting on it) Garcia will be a steal in most drafts.

So, in short, what you are saying is that he may be good, but he may not be good? He may be a steal but he may flame out?

thanks.

[Mookie4ever]

A lot of these top 10 list have Garcia on them. Do ya'll really think he will do that well in Cleveland?

I think that he will do well when he plays.

I also think that he will get the crap pounded out of him and will be injured a lot.

I'm not going to draft him.

[maddog60]

So, in short, what you are saying is that he may be good, but he may not be good? He may be a steal but he may flame out?

thanks.

No in short, I'm saying what I stated in the first sentence of my post. I'd love to get Garcia as my #2 QB, but I wouldn't be too comfortable if he were my #1. Garcia I trust has the skill to be a fantasy QB, its having a suspect O-line, unproven WRs, and a wildcard at TE that bothers me about his situation.

[smackthefirst]

1 - DC
2 - PManning (Man I have to put 'P' as if anyone would think this is Eli)
3 - McNabb
4 - Hassleback
5 - Penny
6 - Vick
7 - Brooks
8 - McNair
9 - Favre
10 - Bulger



SLEEPERS:
Harrington & McNown - Just the weapons around them. Well worth late flyers.

[TheHeat24]

SLEEPERS:
Harrington & McNown - Just the weapons around them. Well worth late flyers.

Easy with the Mcnown talk u almost scared me that Cade was back in the laegue... I think u were refferring to Josh McCown on the Cardinals. I agree he is a big time sleeper along with Leftwhich.

[moochman]

I rate C-Pepp and Manning as clear #1 & 2, with a slight edge to C-Pepp. The rest are a crap shoot given injury and inconsistency issues.
Penny could have a great season starting out healty and having 2 gifted WRs.
The Mc's-I vacillate between which I'd rate higher. McNair loses some for fears of injury, and McNabb because he is such an erractic passer.
Hasselbeck-could be amongst the top if K Rob fulfills his potential.
Brooks, Favre, Bulger, and Brady finish off the list. They could all be top dogs or mediocre.
Harrington could be a big sleeper entering his 3rd season and having some explosive tools at his disposal.