Personally i'd take Moss over Culpepper in the second round. With the RB rankings i think there is a general consensus the top 4 RB are Priest, LT, Green, Portis (in no particular order), after those guys however it gets a bit tricky, you'll get many different opinions on who the next 3-4 RB are and what order they should be in. I would struggle to take Lewis over guys like Deuce, Ricky and maybe even Alexander, esp in leagues that reward receptions. But like i said there's not much between this next tier of players. I did a draft in an 8 team league a few weeks ago where i picked second, i think from memory i went RB, WR, QB, TE, RB.....which was Priest, Harrison, Culpepper, Gonzales, Barlow. So i think in an 8 team league try and get the best player at each position if possible because with a shallow league like yours there will be enough second tier players to around to fill up your roster later on.